|
'Alien' and Ripley. Together. Again. |
Alien³ : Special Edition (1992)
Director: David Fincher
Cast: Sigourney Weaver, Charles S. Dutton, Lance Henriksen
The Special Edition version contains 30 minutes of additional footage. Some of it works in favor of the film and some of it just has no value, except photogenic and slowing down the film in the process. Alien³ was hated all over when it came to theatres two decades ago. Fans were displeased, critics were unimpressed and James Cameron (director of Aliens, the previous installment in the series) was enraged on seeing three primary characters from his film killed in the very opening minutes of Alien³. All I can say is that, this film is really not that bad. This film didn't deserve that kind of hate, though I think I get where all that hate came from. This film is an example of genuine, inspired direction and I'm not saying this on account of being a rabid David Fincher fan; in fact I consider The Game to be his weakest work (unlike what most people think) and just a mediocre B-movie.
So why did I like it?
Well first of all I didn't find the deaths of Newt, Bishop and Hicks to hamper the film in any way. In fact the sudden emotional void, thus created, did a double job - it allowed Ripley to form new, fresh relationships in the space prison, and in a way, also added to the grim and hopeless tone of the film. In fact I found this to be the most depressing film Fincher has ever made. None of the characters, not a single one you root for survives till the end, not to mention, die in horrific ways. All the characters (the prison inmates, I mean) are guilt-ridden, slightly paranoid and both their spiritual and intellectual growth has been stunted due to their dark backgrounds, subsequent repentance and finally, full submission to religion. Add to that, they have double Y or XYY chromosome patterns. I googled it to find out its significance to the story and I came to know that XYY people have lower IQ than usual. All of these provides a reason for why the characters were 'uninteresting' (a common complain about the film) as opposed to those in the previous films. As a result they are always scared, praying or are freaking out, not knowing what to do, and David Fincher is totally spot on in recreating their mental state audio-visually; the empty dim-lit corridors, the wet, iron pipes, the constant smoke, the dark, imposing architecture, the constant hollow hum throughout the film, the brilliant use of light and shadows, sounds of distant banter of deranged inmates filling up the desolate iron rooms as 'the beast' lurks around for its prey - all of these stylistic elements and much more plays an important role in strengthening the film that suffers from a very weak screenplay.
The film is in fact, more of a doomed tragedy, a tale of redemption than it is a monster movie. Moments in the film are just so 'ghostly', that it's almost surreal.
Now why did people hate this film so much? Perhaps they were appalled by the gloomy nature of this film, or maybe, it was the disturbing gore (this is definitely the goriest film of the series, if you count out Alien: Resurrection that was just plain buffoonish with its gore). Perhaps, they expected something on the line of Aliens, after the utterly senseless and misleading promotional campaign by Fox. But without doubt, the ridiculous ending scene of Ripley grabbing the queen alien bursting from her chest, as she fell into the fire, played a pivotal role for attracting so much criticism. Thankfully, they edited the scene out in this version.
All in all, I think the perfect Alien³ lies somewhere between this version and the original theatrical cut. The original was fast but incoherent in plot progression. This one was a bit too long. Good thing is that the colossal failure of Alien³ didn't stop Fincher from making further films or we would've missed SO MUCH.